Cobourg council more than dogs, chickens and boulevards, says councillor

By Robert Washburn

Cobourg Councillor Donna Todd gave a stinging indictment of her colleagues last week in a local radio interview where she slammed the current legislative agenda.

“I would just like to clear the air because we are beginning to look like a pretty bizarre council that only worries about dogs, chickens and boulevards. I would like to get to some real work, like rezoning,” she said.

While a stinging critique, it is also an insight into a council coming into its final year before the 2014 municipal elections. Councillors will be judged on what they accomplish in the next 12 months more than the previous three years.

So, Todd is feeling frustrated.

The dog park issue has sat in stasis for the entire life of this council. Councillor Larry Sherwin religiously keeps promising a solution, but it is not resolved. Negotiations are underway with dog owners. But from a public perspective, nothing is happening. All we see is a crackdown on dog owners in James Cockburn Park after an innovative education campaign last spring.

Now, the issue has grown into a shoving match between the Ganaraska Regional Conservation Authority and the town. Incredibly, Cobourg’s Forrest Rowden is chair of the authority and it is still unresolved, calling into serious question his loyalty and managerial skills. It should never get to this point.

Todd stuck some dynamite in the dam last week as she proposes to walk away from the sharing agreement in a hastily proposed motion. It is a bold, but potentially damaging idea over the long term.

The chickens Todd refers to are the four hens Paul Hoepfner-Homme and Laire Taverner were trying to keep in their backyard. There were threats to remove the chickens by Aug. 19, but the matter was put over for a staff report.

Finally, Todd’s reference to boulevards relates to an ongoing battle between Councillor Miriam Mutton and her supporters over a bylaw past in the spring limiting the height of flowers planted on town boulevards to eight inches.

Despite a bylaw properly approved by a majority of council, Mutton and his friends are unhappy, but unable to move on.

All of this has the flavour of the paralysis of the American government currently shutdown, hurdling towards potential fiscal collapse because of a small group of rogue Tea Party Republicans with nothing to lose and an inflated sense of political power. Like Mutton and company, the Tea Party is still fighting affordable health care even though the law was voted on, a majority won and the Supreme Court says it is legal.

Yes, a dog park, urban farming and boulevard gardens are important issues. And, yes, these issues deserve the time and attention of politicians and town staff. But, Todd’s frustration mirrors a growing sense of annoyance with council to get the job done and quit dragging things out. Identify the issue, negotiation the best you can and make a decision. Sure, some people will not always like the final outcome. Move on. What’s next?

What this all comes down to is bylaw enforcement, nothing more. The random nature of the application of local bylaws no longer works, period.

The days when Cobourg was truly a small town and neighbours knew each other are over. Bylaws could be enforced on a complaint basis because people were reasonable and used common sense. To think bylaws should be applied on a complaint basis today is ridiculous. People are not like this anymore.

So, council finds itself in an awkward position. To admit the bylaw enforcement system is broken is to tarnish the small town atmosphere driving so many Toronto refugees to retire here. It is a blotch on the postcard perfect folksy image the town wants to project.

Yet, until it can come up with a system where bylaws are applied with consistency and regularity, not on a whim, there will be an endless stream of delegations begging for exceptions with their petitions and sob stories pleading for politicians to right perceived wrongs. People need to be heard, but councillors need to be less divided, more compromising, conciliatory, focused and not dissecting everything every time. It should not be this hard.

Todd is right to raise the issue. And, the mayor and councillors should reflect on her concerns, not ignore them.

Finally, don’t think for a moment Todd’s comments were just a smack down of council. It is a clear signal the race for next year’s municipal elections are now underway. And, it appears she is running again.

Originally appeared Oct. 9, 2013

3 thoughts on “Cobourg council more than dogs, chickens and boulevards, says councillor

  1. This is absolutely correct. Sun Media does not like its columnists to refer specifically to other media. I am happy to give credit.Thanks for this clarification. Thank-you.

  2. It would have been helpful and truthful to note that the “local radio interview” was on the brand new “Northumberland 89.7 – Small Town Radio” station. We always ensure to credit our sources and firmly believe that should extend both ways. In fact, Ms. Todd was speaking to our News Director, Mr. John Hill, a lawyer and member, in good standing of the Law Society of Upper Canada.

    Further in this article is the implication that this website’s author discovered the facts himself, when, in fact, it was an excerpt from our program, “Week In Review”, hosted by our Station Manager, Mr. Jeff Caine and Mr. Hill.

    A clarification of sources is requested by the author. Thank you.

  3. This column certainly gives me food for thought. Like many who have been disgusted by how the Old Boys have treated Councillor Mutton over the years, I don’t think it’s changed much under Council’s latest incarnation. Now she finds herself relegated to the dubious status of an oddball who probably wears socks with her Birkenstocks, not an image that fits in with uptight, business oriented Cobourg.

    Now Ms. Mutton has to decide what to do next. Is this the battle she wants to fight to the end? Or should she just give it up and confine her naturalized garden to her own property? Not an easy decision for her, I’m sure. All I can offer for advice is that it’s best to pick our battles, and save the heavy ammunition, Charter of Rights and all, for an issue that is worth the fight and the consequences. I’m not sure this is it.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.