December 26, 2024

2 thoughts on “Community should rededicate itself to protecting women and children

  1. Mr. Day is correct in his point regarding the dangers of being vague. People might wrongly assume it was a veiled reference and that is not what was intended. Let’s hope the overall argument is not severely damaged. Thanks.

  2. “. . . after a woman has behaved in deference to a cultural tradition.” That would be ” in defiance of,” I assume.

    I’m not at all comfortable with the words “cultural tradition” here. In some cases you are looking at a tribal tradition, or even a community tradition. In others, an aberrant group. Attributing such extreme actions to an entire culture does not seem defensible, unless you can show widespread adherance to such a “tradition” which would not be the case in the Shafia murders. Furthermore, if you don’t identify the “culture” to which you refer, careless readers might wrongly assume you mean “Muslims.” I suggest this whole “cultural tradition” language needs serious examination.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.